Former New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning may not be inducted into the Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility. One Pro Football Hall of Fame

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. -- Eli Manning has faced doubters before. Entering the 2007 playoffs, when the quarterback led the New York Giants on a Super Bowl run that ended in an upset win over the previously undefeated New England Patriots, there were questions about whether he was built for pressure situations.

Because according to pro football historian Jack Silverstein (@ readjack.bsky.social on BlueSky), Manning is now basically a lock to one day enter the Hall of Fame based on his being a first-ballot semifinalist. Be it this year or somewhere down the line, Manning will soon get a bronze bust of his head.

Should former New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning be in the Hall of Fame? Nick Wright opined why the answer is "no."

Two-time Super Bowl MVP Eli Manning, prolific tight end Antonio Gates and dominant pass rusher Jared Allen are among the 25 modern-era candidates for the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame class

There are 25 of them in line for Canton. So how do they stack up? Historian John Turney with his review of the candidates.

Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame candidacy sparks debate, with polarizing arguments that could delay his induction despite his iconic Super Bowl success.